MEDICAL CHANNEL
Quarterly Peer-Reviewed Journal, Karachi Pakistan
ISSN: 1681-5491 | ONLINE ISSN: 2077-9135 | PMDC IP No: 0045 | CPSP S. No: 30
Compliant with COPE, ICMJE, NLM Guidelines
1. PREAMBLE Medical Channel is committed to maintaining integrity of scientific record. Corrections and retractions are issued when errors affect understanding or when misconduct is proven. We follow COPE Core Practices.
2. DEFINITIONS (As per COPE / NLM)A) Erratum / Correction:
Correction of an error that does NOT affect conclusions but needs to be fixed to avoid misleading readers. Error introduced by journal/publisher. Example: Wrong affiliation, typo in figure legend, author name spelling. B) Corrigendum:
Correction of an error that DOES affect content but introduced by authors. Authors request correction. Example: Wrong p-value, missed acknowledgement, incorrect dosage that doesn’t change conclusion.
C) Expression of Concern (EoC):
Notice issued when investigation is ongoing and outcome may affect reliability, but not yet conclusive.
D) Retraction:
Withdrawal of published article because findings are unreliable due to error or misconduct, or ethical violation.
E) Removal: Only in exceptional cases (e.g., court order, serious patient privacy breach). Article text removed but metadata retained.3. WHEN TO ISSUE CORRECTION (Erratum / Corrigendum)Correction will be issued for: Minor errors in data that do not affect conclusions (e.g., mislabeled axis, typo in table)Author name, affiliation, order error Omission of funding source or conflict of interest Omission of acknowledgement or author contribution Error in ethical approval No. or trial registration No. Procedure for Correction: Author contacts EIC at editor@quarterlymedicalchannel.pk with details of error and corrected version .EIC assesses if error is minor and warrants correction. If approved, Correction Notice is published in next issue, linked to original article, and online version corrected with footnote. Correction is free of charge. Format : CORRIGENDUM: In article [Title, Med Channel Vol, Issue, Year, Pages], the should read as. The original article has been corrected online.[error][corrected]
4. WHEN TO ISSUE RETRACTION Retraction will be considered if:
A) Scientific Misconduct: Fabrication, falsification of data, images Plagiarism (>19% or major copy without citation)Duplicate / redundant publication (same data published elsewhere without disclosure)
B) Ethical Misconduct: No IRB/ERC approval or forged approval No informed consent for human studies Animal cruelty without approval Undisclosed major conflict of interest that affects interpretation
C) Honest Error Making Findings Unreliable: Major error in methodology, statistics, data analysis making conclusions invalid
D) Authorship Dispute That Cannot Be Resolved: Legal issues, court order Retraction is NOT for: Minor errors that can be corrected Disagreements among authors about conclusions Author’s wish to publish elsewhere5. RETRACTION PROCEDURE (As per COPE Flowcharts)Stage 1: Allegation received → EIC does preliminary investigation (requests raw data, proof from authors) → 21 days for author response.
Stage 2: If misconduct / major error confirmed: EIC consults Section Editor + 1 external expert. Decision to retract taken by EIC.
Stage 3: Authors informed. If authors agree: Retraction is by authors + editors. If authors do not agree: Editors may retract without authors’ consent after informing institution.
Stage 4: Retraction Notice Published: Format of Retraction Notice (Mandatory as per NLM):RETRACTION: [Original Title]
Med Channel Vol: Issue: Year: Pages
DOI: [if available]
The article by published in Med Channel is retracted.
Reason: [Clearly state: e.g., “Due to plagiarism of…”, “Due to fabricated data in Table 2…”, “Due to lack of ethical approval”]
This retraction is issued following investigation as per COPE guidelines and approval by Editor-in-Chief.
Authors: [Agree/Disagree]
Date:[Title][Authors][citation][Date]
Stage 5: Actions: Online article remains but watermarked “RETRACTED” on each page – NOT deleted (to preserve record).Retraction notice is open access, linked to original article in both directions (CrossRef).PDF of original article remains with retraction watermark. PubMed / Google Scholar / PakMediNet / Index Copernicus informed. Author’s institution, PMDC, CPSP notified for major misconduct. Authors banned from submission for 3-5 years.6. EXPRESSION OF CONCERN (EoC)Issued when: Investigation is ongoing (>3 months)Inconclusive evidence but serious concerns raised Format: EoC published in next issue, linked to article, stating: “Expression of Concern regarding article… investigation ongoing.” If investigation concludes no misconduct: EoC replaced with exoneration notice. If misconduct: EoC replaced with Retraction.7. AUTHOR RESPONSIBILITIES Authors must report errors immediately after publication to EIC .All authors must sign Retraction or Correction agreement (if possible).Authors must cooperate with investigation and provide raw data within 14 days.8. VERSION CONTROL Original article corrected online only after Correction/Retraction notice published. All versions (original, corrected, retracted) retained in archive .CrossMark button updated on website.
9. CONTACT Editor-in-Chief, Medical Channel
Email: editor@quarterlymedicalchannel.pk
Subject: Correction/Retraction Request – Manuscript No. MC-XXXX This is Policy No. 9 for your PMDC file.
