For Peer Review Medical JournalPeer review is the backbone of scientific quality.
We appreciate your time and expertise. Please follow these guidelines.1. Accepting the Invitation
1. Accepting the Invitation
Please respond within 48 hours. Review should be completed in 14-21 days. If you cannot review, please suggest an alternative expert. All manuscripts are confidential.
2. Conflicts of Interest
Decline if you have collaborated with authors in last 3 years, are from same institution, or have financial/personal interest. Do not use manuscript data for your own work.
3. How to Review? Evaluate:
Originality: Is it novel and relevant?
Methodology: Is study design appropriate?
Statistics: Appropriate and correctly reported?
Sample size justified?
Ethical approval & consent present?
Trial registered?
Results: Clear, accurate, not over-interpreted?
Tables/Figures appropriate
Ethics: Any plagiarism, duplication, or ethical concerns?
4. Your Review Report Should Include:
Confidential Comments to Editor: Recommendation + any ethical concerns.
Comments to Authors: Be constructive and respect
- Brief summary of study
- Major comments (must be addressed)
- Minor comments (grammar, formatting, references)Do not reveal your decision (Ac cept/Reject) in comments to authors.
5. Recommendation
Choose one:Accept | Minor Revision | Major Revision | Reject
6. Ethics & Professionalism
Be objective, unbiased, and respectful. Focus on the work, not the authors. Report suspected misconduct to Editor confidentially.
Final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief.
