MEDICAL CHANNEL
Quarterly Peer-Reviewed Journal, Karachi Pakistan
ISSN: 1681-5491 | ONLINE ISSN: 2077-9135 | PMDC IP No: 0045 | CPSP S. No: 30
Compliant with COPE Flowcharts, ICMJE, PMDC Regulations
1. DEFINITION OF MISCONDUCT Medical Channel defines research and publication misconduct as per COPE: Fabrication: Making up data or results. Falsification: Manipulating research materials, images, data. Plagiarism: Copying ideas, text, figures without credit (>19% similarity, or verbatim >100 words)Duplicate/Redundant Publication: Publishing same data in two journals. Authorship Misconduct: Gift, ghost, guest authorship; omission of deserving author; change of authorship without consent. Undisclosed Conflict of Interest Unethical Research: No IRB/ERC approval, no informed consent, animal cruelty. Reviewer Misconduct: Breach of confidentiality, stealing ideas, biased review.AI Misconduct: Undisclosed use of Generative AI to create data/text, or listing AI as author.
2. WHO CAN RAISE AN ALLEGATION? Authors, Reviewers, Readers, Editors, Institutions, Whistleblowers. Allegations can be submitted confidentially to: editor@quarterlymedicalchannel.pk. Anonymous allegations will be considered if accompanied by evidence.
3. GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF HANDLING Confidentiality: All investigations are strictly confidential. Only EIC, Managing Editor, and concerned Section Editor involved. Neutrality: No presumption of guilt. Both complainant and accused heard. No Retaliation: Protection of whistleblower. Documentation: Every step documented. Timeliness: Acknowledgement within 7 days, initial assessment within 21 days.
4. PROCEDURE –
6 STAGE COPE-BASED PROCESSSTAGE
1: Receipt & Acknowledgement (Day 1-7) Managing Editor logs complaint: Date, Complainant, Manuscript ID, Type of misconduct, Evidence. Acknowledge receipt to complainant. Do not contact accused yet.
STAGE 2: Initial Assessment by Editor-in-Chief (Day 8-21)EIC assesses if allegation is within scope and has prima facie evidence. If frivolous / no evidence: Close with letter to complainant. If potential misconduct: Proceed to Stage
3.STAGE 3: Preliminary Investigation (Day 22-45)EIC reviews manuscript, Turnitin report, raw data, ethical approval letters, COPE Flowchart consulted. For plagiarism: Compare sources. For data fraud: Request raw data, ethics approval proof from authors. Authors contacted for explanation: 14 days to respond with evidence.
STAGE 4: Decision
A) No Misconduct Found: Case closed. Inform both parties.
B) Minor Misconduct (e.g., poor citation, unintentional overlap):Educate authors, request correction / citation / erratum. C) Major Misconduct Found: If manuscript under review: Reject manuscript. Inform authors. Inform institution/HOD if serious (fabrication).If manuscript already published: Issue retraction or Expression of Concern as per COPE Retraction Guidelines.
STAGE 5: Actions & Sanctions (As per COPE)Rejection of manuscript Retraction of published article with watermark “RETRACTED” Publication of Correction / Erratum / Expression of Concern Ban on authors from submitting to Medical Channel for 2-5 years Notification to: Author’s institution, HOD, ERC, PMDC, CPSP, funding body For plagiarism: Report to HEC Quality Assurance Division For reviewer misconduct: Removal from reviewers database, notification to reviewer’s institution
STAGE 6: Documentation & Closure Complete investigation file retained for 5 years. Annual report of misconduct cases presented in Editorial Board Meeting (anonymized).
5. SPECIFIC FLOWCHARTS FOLLOWED (COPE)Medical Channel follows COPE flowcharts for: Suspected plagiarism in submitted manuscript Suspected plagiarism in published article Suspected fabricated data in submitted manuscript Suspected fabricated data in published article Suspected ghost/guest/gift authorship Suspected undisclosed conflict of interest Suspected ethical problem How to handle complaints against editors Full flowcharts: https://publicationethics.org/guidance/Flowcharts
6. RETRACTION POLICY Retraction will be issued if: Clear evidence of unreliable findings due to misconduct or error Plagiarism / duplicate publication Unethical research Undisclosed major COI affecting interpretation Retraction notice will be: Linked to original article, clearly titled “RETRACTION:” State reason, who is retracting Original article remains online with RETRACTED watermark, not removed
7. APPEALS Authors may appeal against decision within 30 days with new evidence. Appeal reviewed by EIC + 1 independent senior editor not involved in original investigation. Decision of EIC on appeal is final.8. CONTACT FOR ALLEGATIONS Editor-in-Chief, Medical Channel
Email: editor@quarterlymedicalchannel.pk
All complaints treated as strictly confidential. Required Forms for Office File:Misconduct Allegation Log Register Author Response Form Retraction Notice Template This is your Policy No.
