MEDICAL CHANNEL Quarterly
Peer-Reviewed Journal, Karachi Pakistan
ISSN: 1681-5491 | ONLINE ISSN: 2077-9135 | PMDC IP No: 0045 | CPSP S. No: 30
Established: 1995 | Frequency: Quarterly (Jan-Mar, Apr-Jun, Jul-Sep, Oct-Dec)
Compliant with ICMJE, COPE, WAME, PMDC Regulations 2024
1. EDITORIAL GOVERNANCE STRUCTURE
A) Editorial Board:
Patron: Editor-in-Chief (EIC): Prof. Dr.Iqbal A Memon, MBBS, FCPS, etc. Managing Editor: Dr. Rufina Soomro MBBS, FCPS Section Editors (Medicine, Surgery, Gynae, Paeds, Basic Sciences, Public Health) Statistical Editor: Biostatistician MBBS, MPH, 15 National+5 International Advisory Board Members
B) Independence: Editorial decisions are independent of publisher/owner. No interference in acceptance/rejection.
2. 12-STEP QUALITY CONTROL PROCESS
STEP 1: Initial Triage (Day 1-3) – Managing Editor
Check: Scope relevance, plagiarism, completeness of forms (Ethical Approval, Consent, Authorship, Copyright, Conflict of Interest) Rejection without review: Out of scope, >19% similarity, missing ethical approval, duplicate submission.
STEP 2: Plagiarism Check (Mandatory)
Tool: Turnitin / iThenticate Criteria: Overall similarity <19%, single source <5%Report attached to manuscript file. High similarity = immediate return to authors.
STEP 3: Technical Editing Check (Day 3-5)
Check ICMJE formatting, structured abstract, references (Vancouver style), units, tables, figures, word count.
Checklist: Ethical statement, Trial registration No., Consent statement, AI disclosure, Funding statement.
STEP 4: Assignment to Section Editor (Day 5)
EIC assigns to relevant Section Editor based on specialty.
STEP 5: Peer Review – DOUBLE-BLIND (Day 6-30)
Minimum 2 independent external reviewers + 1 statistical reviewer for all original articles. Reviewers selected from reviewers database (min. FCPS/MCPS/PhD + 5 publications). No reviewers from same institution as authors. Review form: 20-point structured form (Originality, Methodology, Statistics, Ethics, Relevance, Language).Timeline: 14 days to review, 7 days reminder. Decision: Accept / Minor Revision / Major Revision / Reject
STEP 6: Statistical Review (Mandatory for Original Articles/RCTs)
Separate statistical review by Statistical Editor for sample size, p-values, tests applied, CONSORT/STROBE compliance.
STEP 7: Ethics & AI Check
Verify IRB/ERC No. from institution, Trial Registration No. from ClinicalTrials.gov, Patient consent forms if needed. Check Generative AI disclosure as per AI Policy.
STEP 8: Author Revision (Day 31-45)
Authors given 21 days for revision. Must submit point-by-point response letter + revised manuscript with track changes. Revised version re-evaluated by Section Editor (and reviewers if major revision).
STEP 9: Final Decision by Editor-in-Chief (Day 46-50)
EIC takes final decision based on reviewers’ recommendations. EIC decision is final. Acceptance letter issued with article reference No. MC-YYYY-###
STEP 10: Copyediting & Proofreading (Day 51-60)
Professional copyeditor: Grammar, language, formatting. Proof sent to corresponding author for final approval (72 hours).DOI assignment (if applicable) + Cross Mark.
STEP 11: Online & Print Publication
Online First on www.medicalchannel.pk before print. Print quarterly as per schedule. 4 issues per year, 15-20 articles per issue.
STEP 12: Post-Publication Quality
Reader comments / Letters to Editor accepted. Corrections / Erratum / Retraction as per COPE if needed .Long-term archiving: Journal website, PakMediNet, Index Copernicus, Google Scholar.
3. QUALITY INDICATORS & KPIs Indicator Target Monitored By Plagiarism check for all submissions100%Managing Editor Double-blind external peer review100%Section Editor Average Submission to First Decision<30 days EIC Average Submission to Publication<90 days EIC Reviewer response rate70%Managing Editor Ethical approval verification100%Ethics Editor Rejection rate40-50% (maintains quality)EIC
4. REVIEWER QUALITY CONTROL
Reviewers database updated annually with qualifications, H-index, specialty. Reviewers scoring system: Timeliness + Quality of review. Poor reviewers removed. Recognition: Certificate of Reviewer + name listed in Annual Issue. Conflict of Interest declaration mandatory for reviewers.5. EDITORIAL TRAINING & AUDIT
Annual Editorial Board Meeting (Minutes documented) Internal audit every 6 months of 10% random articles for adherence to QCS External audit by PMDC / CPSP as required6.
COMPLAINTS & APPEALS
Complaints about peer review handled by EIC, not by same Section Editor. Appeals against rejection allowed once with justification letter. EIC may send to 3rd reviewer .All appeals documented.
7. DOCUMENTATION FOR PMDC
Medical Channel maintains:
Original review forms (signed)Turnitin reports Ethical approval letters Author forms (Authorship, Copyright, COI, Consent )Editorial decision letters Retention: 5 years.
This QCS document completes your 7-policy file for PMDC renewal and CPSP recognition:
