Authors: Syed Mukkaram Ali, Ramlah Naz, Lubna Ali, Ahmed Moiz, Mehwish Mansoori
Abstract
To determine the patern of hard and blunt injuries in custodial deaths in Karachi: An autopsy based study Background: The death in captivity is considered as custodial deaths which are reported not only in Pakistan but its neighbor countries like India, Middle East and even from developed countries. In custodial deaths autopsy becomes a necessary part of investigation. There are various natural and unnatural causes of custodial death. The objectives of this study are to identify the pattern of blunt injuries from autopsies of individuals died in custody, to know and analyze the trends of blunt injuries and physical and psychological effects on the victim’s family. Methodology: Study design: This was a cross sectional study of 96 autopsy reports of custodial deaths. Study Setting: All prisoners were male with age group ranging from 33 to 38 years. The data was collected for five years from February 2010 to February 2015. These autopsies were conducted in the three major hospitals of Karachi (Abbasi Shaheed Hospital, Civil Hospital and Jinnah Hospital) under the supervision of police surgeon of Karachi. Duration: The data were collected for five years from February 2010 to February 2015. Inclusion / Exclusion Criteria: The data were taken for five years and the data before that period were excluded. Ethical Consideration: This study was conducted after the administrative approval of Police Surgeon Department Karachi Results: The deaths were found in the age group ranging from 33 to 38 years. Observation of different patterns of injuries in table 02 revealed that contusion/ bruises has the highest percentage (42.6%) among other patterns. It was found that hypovolemic shocks was the major cause of death i.e., 44% in individuals died in custodial death due to hard and blunt injury. It is shown in table 04 that around 46% custodial deaths due to hard and blunt injury were homicidal. Conclusion: In Pakistan around 42% of deaths is custody are due to hard and blunt injuries. Torture should be avoided under all circumstances. Most of the cases of custodial death came up with death due to hard and blunt injuries and all were adult males, the most common part involved was cranial cavity followed by neck, throat, abdomen and pelvis and were homicidal in nature.
Keywords: Hard and blunt injuries, Custodial death, Autopsy
