Authors: Zia-Uddin A. Kashmiri, Shoaib Ahmed Gangat, Anjum Rehman
Abstract
To compare the effect of General anaesthesia (G.A) versus Spinal anaesthesia
(S.A) upon neonatal well being in terms of Apgar scoring and Umblical artery blood
pH after lower segment caesarean section (LSCS). Study Design: This was a randomized, prospective, interventional, quasi- experimental study. Place & duration of study: This study was conducted at the department of Anaesthesiology, Surgical.I.C.U., and pain management clinic, Civil Hospital Karachi and Dow University Hospital, Dow University of Health Sciences, for the period of two years i.e. from May 2009 to June 2011. Patients & Methods: 200 pts, aged between 18 – 45yrs, ASA-I & II, with singleton pregnancy, undergoing Elective LSCS were randomly divided in to 2 groups, General anesthesia (G.A.) group & Spinal anaesthesia (S.A.) group, each group having 100 patients, randomization was done by envelope draw method. This study was based on 2 proformas, Intra-operative proforma& Baby’s proforma. Apgar scoring at 1 min & 5 min after birth was done.Umblical artery blood sample was taken for estimation of its pH. Results of the 2 groups were analysed by “Chi.Square test” with P value less than 0.05 was considered statistically significant. Results: In our study we have found that S.A. group is a associated with better Apgar Score at 1min. as compare to the G.A. group, as 68 babies out of 100 had Apgar Score of 7 or >7 after 1min. in the S.A. group as compared to only 16 babies out of 100 had Apgar Score of 7 or >7 in the G.A. group. Whereas the Apgar Score after 5min. were approximately the same in the both groups ,so poor Apgar score (6 or < 6)after 1minute in the GA group is statistically significant (84% VS 32% ) P<0.001 whereas after
5minutes it is statistically insignificant (3% VS 0%) P=0.246 Umblical artery blood pH in the GA group is 7.298 +0.07 and that of SA group it is 7.248 + 0.06 with P<0.01 which is statistically significant. Conclusion: This study concludes that SA is associated with better neo-natal outcome as compared to GA, as the Apgar Score of the SA group was better than the GA group after 1min, and the Apgar Score were approximately same after 5 min. in the both G.A. and S.A. group. But the Umblical artery blood pH in the SA group is more academic as compare to the GA group.
Keywords: G.A, SA, & LSCS. Apgar Score.Umblical artery blood pH.
