Authors: Shahid Hussain Mirani, Ghulam Haider Rind, Syed Qarib Abbas, Ali Gohar Bozdar, Saima Javed
Abstract
Milligan-Morgan excision haemorrhoidectomy remains a very popular
treatment modality for third and fourth degree hemorrhoids due to its cost effectiveness
and better long-term results. Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy is believed to result in less
postoperative pain because of a closed wound. The aim of this study was to compare
the effectiveness of Milligan-Morgan excision hemorrhoidectomy with Ferguson
hemorrhoidectomy, METHODS: A prospective clinical trial was conducted. Patients with newly diagnosed hemorrhoids requiring hemorrhoidectomy were randomized to either Milligan-Morgan excision hemorrhoidectomy or Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy. Surgical technique and prospective care was standardized. Outcome measures were operative time and bleeding, postoperative pain (measured on visual analogue scale) and rate of wound healing. RESULTS: We randomized 140 patients, 70 to Milligan-Morgan excision hemorrhoidectomy and 70 to Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy; after taking an informed consent from every individual, 140 patients were evaluated. They were aged between 19 and 71 years. There were no differences in patient demographics or type of hemorrhoid being operated on. Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy had a significantly longer mean operative time and minor problems of bleeding, wound discharge and pruritis. At 3 weeks after surgery, Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy had an odds ratio for complete epithelization of 3.1 over Milligan-Morgan excision hemorrhoidectomy. There was less postoperative pain in Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy. CONCLUSION: Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy is superior to Milligan-Morgan excision hemorrhoidectomy.
Keywords: Milligan -Morgan excision hemorrhoidectomy, Ferguson hemorrhoidectomy, Wound healing, Pain.
