UNDER GRADUATE SUMMATIVE OSCE RATING- IS THERE A NEED FOR IMPROVEMENT?

Authors: Gulshan Ara Saeed, Shazia Fakhar, Tasneem Akhtar, Anjum Ara Saeed

1. SHIFA COLLEGE OF MEDICINE ISLAMABAD, PAKISTAN
2. SHIFA COLLEGE OF MEDICINE ISLAMABAD, PAKISTAN
3. SHIFA COLLEGE OF MEDICINE ISLAMABAD, PAKISTAN
4. PAKISTAN AIR FORCE HOSPITAL ISLAMABAD, PAKISTAN.

Volume 20 | Issue 1

Published: November 4, 2026

Abstract

Medical schools across Pakistan are shifting from pure knowledge based assessments to competency based evaluations. The emphasis is to evaluate something more than what a student knows. Objective structured clinical examination is an assessment of student skills and is being involved in the undergraduate curriculum on both a formative and summative basis. Summative OSCE evaluations have long been evaluated through the checklist method as it is felt to give a detailed point to point evaluation of the students performance. We in our study compared the two methods of OSCE rating (global rating and checklist method) in predicting the actual performance (final scores) of the students. Subjects: Final year medical students of Shifa College of medicine, Islamabad, Pakistan. Methods: Seventy seven students underwent through a series of ten OSCE stations in the subject of obstetrics and Gynecology. These students were rated by the global rating and the checklist method. Student scores by these two methods were regressed against their final score to see any correlation . Results: Global and checklist rating had significant correlation with the final student score. But when forward regression was calculated, in which Marks A and B were regressed against dependent variable (final score).Marks A stood as a significant predictor of final score. (P value <0.001). R- square of Marks A was 0.223. Hence: Final score = 223.86+(1.918 X Marks A) Conclusion: Global rating of student OSCE provides a much better assessment of the students knowledge and skills.

Keywords: comparative analysis, global rating, checklist evaluations, OSCE scoring

DOI: (All papers should be submitted electronically. All submitted manuscripts must be original work that is not under submission at another journal or under consideration for publication in another form, such as a monograph or chapter of a book. Authors of submitted papers are obligated not to submit their paper for publication elsewhere until an editorial decision is rendered on their submission. Further, authors of accepted papers are prohibited from publishing the results in other publications that appear before the paper is published in the Journal unless they receive approval for doing so from the EditorIn-Chief.)